DROWNING IN DEBT?
Excerpt from AOL Personal Finance
FACING A STACK of
bills you can't handle? Take heart. Plenty of nonprofit
organizations are out there, eager to help you climb out of debt.
Late in 1998, 27-year-old Thomas King examined his credit card
statements and came to an unsettling realization: He was still
carrying debts he ran up during his college years. The San
Antonio, Texas, customer-service rep was $6,000 in hock — thanks
to three credit cards, a bank line of credit, a huge cellular
phone bill and a Radio Shack card he'd maxed out to buy a
computer. "I went a little too nuts on credit," King
admits. "And making minimum payments wasn't moving the bill
at all."
At least King's new computer came in handy. He surfed the
Internet and found Metropolitan
Financial Management, a Roseville, Minn.-based nonprofit that
helps debt-ridden consumers reorganize their finances and start
paying down their loans. King filled out the company's online
application, which asked for information on his debt. He paid a
$25 registration fee. (After that, Metropolitan charges up to $35
as a monthly maintenance fee, depending on the debtor's financial
circumstances.) Metropolitan then began negotiating with his
creditors, eliminating late fees, trimming as much as 12% off his
credit-card interest rates and, in one case, eliminating the
interest entirely.
King's new payment plan, developed by Metropolitan, allows him
to send in one monthly check for $195, which Metropolitan
disburses to his creditors. A year later, he has paid off his
three largest debts and figures he'll be debt-free sometime in
2000.
King is hardly alone — in fact, he's in better shape than
many. The National
Foundation for Consumer Credit (NFCC) last year counseled 1.6
million American households through its 190 member organizations.
A third of those decided to participate in a debt-repayment plan.
Mike Kidwell, vice president of Debt
Counselors of America, says his organization's average client
holds six credit cards and is $18,000 in debt. While many, like
King, got into debt when they were students, naive about
credit-card interest rates and late fees, Kidwell says he's seen
lawyers and judges — even financial planners and CPAs — seek
help in eliminating personal debt. Often they've run into trouble
because of a life-changing event like a job loss, death, illness
or divorce.
Most Americans can't just flip open a checkbook and wipe out
$18,000 worth of unpaid bills. But plenty of reputable
organizations are out there willing to help you negotiate a
manageable schedule to repay your debts and to see where you've
been overspending. Unfortunately, there are some not-so-honorable
companies as well — ones hoping to profit from your desperation
and employing high-pressure sales tactics to get you to sign with
them. Many offer little more than a quick road to bankruptcy
court, which should always be a last resort.
Before you pay an outside counselor for help, however, you
should be sure that you've tried all the easy solutions first. For
instance, have you considered a loan from a family member? You
should also consider a loan from your 401(k). Limits are as high
as $50,000.
And have you considered consolidating your debt on a
low-interest rate credit card or tax-deductible home equity loan?
Finally, we have to ask you the obvious. Have you tried to cut
your expenses? Why not track your spending for a few months, then
see what you can eliminate. This is probably the quickest avenue
to debt reduction.
Choosing a Debt
Counselor
Finding a good credit-counseling program can be a bit tricky.
After all, it's not something you'd want to bring up with
colleagues around the company water cooler. That means you'll have
to do the legwork on your own. But there are a few things to keep
in mind to make the task easier and less fraught with
disappointment.
First, look for a nonprofit firm. You've spent too much
already, why pay more now? Nonprofits get most of their funding
from creditors, not you. Privacy isn't usually an issue, but it's
wise to check what the agency's policy is. Make sure they don't
sell your information. Many ask for only a nominal fee to enroll.
Debt Counselors of America, for instance, has a suggested donation
of $60. And the nonprofits' relationship with the debt community
has an added benefit. They can often negotiate better rates with
those same creditors on your behalf.
Second, find out upfront exactly what services you'll receive,
such as counseling, a debt-repayment plan and budgeting advice.
The more services, the better. You might want to have them put it
all in writing and send you the information before you proceed.
And ask if the organization belongs to any professional groups,
such as the NFCC or the Better Business Bureau. Have them explain
how they're audited and if your funds are protected. After all,
you're sending them your money. Debt Counselors of America posts a
list of credit and debt-counseling scams to watch out for on its
Web site, as well as questions to ask organizations offering to
help you out of debt.
One-Pay Plans
Once you've found a service you trust, pull all your bills
together before talking to a credit counselor. She will figure out
what you owe and work with you to determine how much you can pay
each month. Then, instead of writing checks to each creditor,
you'll write one to the service, which will then distribute the
money. The goal is to develop a plan that allows you to afford the
necessities of life (even if that includes an occasional movie),
and at the same time to whittle away at the balances you owe.
According to Kidwell, most of his agency's customers are able to
pay off their debt within four to six years.
Once you're in a program, the much-dreaded phone calls from
creditors should stop. "Creditors have a right to call you
and talk to you about your debt," says Catherine Williams,
president of the Consumer
Credit Counseling Service of Greater Chicago. "But if you
arrange acceptable payment programs, they're not going to waste
their time." (If you find yourself being harassed
unreasonably by creditors, check with the Consumer
Aid Education Center for guidelines on how to handle such
calls.)
Negotiators at Your
Service
Once you've set up a payment schedule, the counselor will talk to
creditors and try to get them to reduce your interest rates and
waive late fees to shorten your time in debt. The counselor may
also coax creditors to "re-age" your account — that
is, report past due amounts as current.
How come credit counselors have so much clout? Most creditors
are glad to see you enrolling in a repayment program, agreeing to
pay a little at a time, rather than heading for bankruptcy court.
If those same creditors were to enlist the services of a
collection agency, the agency would take perhaps half of whatever
it recovered. So, it's a better deal for your creditors if you
voluntarily repay, even if it takes several years.
What's more, because such repayment organizations have existing
relationships with creditors, they know what that creditor has
arranged for other clients. If you tried to negotiate on your own,
chances are you wouldn't be as successful. "[The consumer]
doesn't know the best terms available," says Debt Counselors
of America's Kidwell. "A lot of people set themselves up for
failure. They'll say what they think the creditor wants to hear,
or they feel bullied."
If a one-pay plan is not enough to solve your problem, you
might need to consider a debt-consolidation loan. "It can be
beneficial if the rates are low," Kidwell says. An interest
rate of 8% or 9% beats the 16% you might be paying on a credit
card.
Budgeting 101
Once you're on your way to paying off your old debt, you'll need
to set up a budget. Credit counselors can help with that as well.
Most people don't know how much they spend each day. They may know
about the big-ticket items, the rent and mortgage payments and the
utility bills. But they lose track of how much they spend on
extras like restaurants, dry cleaners and video rentals. "If
you take a piece of paper and write down everything you spend, not
including the change, you'll be shocked at how much money you go
through that you don't realize," says Jim Rhodes, director of
education at Metropolitan Financial.
Williams thinks the American "market of convenience,"
in which plastic pays for everything, has obscured how much things
really cost. "Ten years ago, it used to be, 'Got to wait
until Saturday to call Grandma,' or, 'Got to keep that thermostat
down,'" Williams says. "But some people have just gotten
away from budgeting and money management."
Counselors can help you track your spending. They teach you to
record what you pay right down to the newspaper, bagel and mocha
latte you grab on your way to work. Counselors on Williams' staff
are trained to walk debtors through every category and come up
with an acceptable budget. The counselors check in with clients
for several months to see how well they're sticking to their
spending plan.
Many of these services can show you how your spending habits
stack up to those of a "typical" American with your
income. For instance, Kidwell says the average person spends $150
per month on food — not including restaurant meals. (This varies
by location, of course.) So, if you're spending more, it's time to
reconsider.
A Word of Warning...
If you've somehow managed to keep your credit report clean as your
debts have spiraled, you need to know there can be a downside to
contacting a credit counselor. Not every creditor looks upon your
involvement with one as a good thing. While many creditors think
it's great because it increases their chances of getting paid,
others might issue an alert on your credit report. That could
affect your chances of getting credit down the road.
Not exactly what you're aiming for here. Is it worth the risk?
That's something you'll have to decide — weighing the chances
your credit report will take a beating anyway if you keep falling
further behind.
|